Film review by Ethlie Ann Vare
LOS ANGELES (The Hollywood Times, Nov. 18) – I am almost the perfect target audience for Elsinore, the poignant story of actor Ian Charleson’s final performances at the National Theatre in London. I remember the AIDS pandemic. I saw Charleson in Chariots of Fire in an actual movie theater, and I can still hum the soundtrack. (People humming that earworm is a running gag in Elsinore.) I can also recite most of Hamlet’s soliloquies. If I were a gay man, it would be a bullseye.
Will the movie resonate as much if you weren’t born when all the smart, funny theater queens were dropping dead around you? When there was nothing anyone could do about HIV other than cling to friends, make very dark jokes, and play the one role you have longed for your whole life? I don’t know if the subject matter will hit the same way for another generation, but I suspect that Andrew Scott’s performance will resonate just as strongly. Sure, it has “Oscar bait” written all over it. But it pierces the heart all the same.
Scott has been around a lot longer than that, but most of us met him as Hot Priest in Fleabag, which means Elsinore reunites him with Olivia Colman who also had a co-starring role in the BBC comedy. Each has had a hell of a career ascendance since then, and they play perfectly off each other here. Colman, almost unrecognizable as a blonde, plays Dr. Margaret Johnson, who opened the first HIV/AIDS clinic in England. She is just hoping to keep her patients alive long enough that researchers can find a cure and she takes it personally when one of them would rather act than cooperate. (Dr. Johnson is a real person, alive and practicing today.)
Elsinore opens in 1989. Ian Charleson has just been diagnosed with AIDS, a situation he deflects with graveyard humor and a coterie of smart, funny, loyal friends. Billie Piper (Rose from Doctor Who) is a whirligig of loving energy as the straight lady counterpart of the gay bestie. A casting director, she’s one of the first to learn that Daniel Day-Lewis walked off the stage mid-performance (yes, that really happened) and that the part of Hamlet will be offered to Charleson.

Telling no one but director Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn, MobLand) about his diagnosis and against the express wishes of his doctor, Charleson takes on one of the most demanding roles in English literature. What is a few more months of life compared to Shakespeare? What is the point of living if you don’t live? Better to go out with a bang than a whimper.

The tragedy of Hamlet is the perfect dramatic counterpoint to the tragedy of AIDS, and director Simon Stone and screenwriter Stephen Beresford do a seamless job of stitching the themes and scenes together. Both are stories of mortality, of subterfuge, of betrayal… stories of forbidden love and even stories of poisoned blood. When Hamlet contemplates the skull of Yorick, “a fellow of infinite jest,” Ian is also thinking about his former lover Georgie (Luke Thompson) who always had a twinkle in his eye… until he didn’t.
Are there some overly sentimental heart-tuggers here? Sure. Is the score occasionally overbearing? Also, sure. Would I rather see more Hamlet and more humor (it’s quite funny, believe it or not) and less chemotherapy? Again sure. Will people get confused between this and the far inferior Hamnet? Probably not.
The writers of Elsinore, La Bola Negra and Club Kid say they grew up without seeing gay men honestly represented in mainstream movies. This Oscar season could make up for that in one fell swoop.
ELSINORE – distributed by Focus Features
Director: Simon Stone
Screenwriter: Stephen Beresford (based on an idea by Ethan Silverman)
Cast: Andrew Scott (Ian Charleson), Olivia Colman (Dr. Margaret Johnson), Billie Piper (Patsy Pollock), Johnny Flynn (Richard Eyre)
Release Date: In theaters November 20, 2026



